7 Comments
User's avatar
Sham's avatar

Another excellent essay Adam. Doing wonderful work! Also reaffirming my decision to leave science. I just know based on my nationality, experience & gender I will not be able to make it without becoming poor & depressed. But I highly admire you, will read your research & wish you the best.

Adam Rochussen's avatar

Very kind. Thank you!

Anytime anyone takes agency over their life and makes rational decisions, the outcome is ultimately good. Sounds like this seems to apply to you :)

Pamela Hobart's avatar

Oh my goodness you kinda buried the lede, abolishing tenure and IQ-testing and retesting for profs!! not necessarily personally opposed though, would like to hear more about this in future pieces. Am now 40yo myself and can feel my memory slowing a touch, it's horrifying.

Adam Rochussen's avatar

I wanted to convince readers of the problem before I hit them with the radical solutions 😂

The cognitive ageing stuff can feel depressing. I definitely think I’m less sharp now than I was at 20. Obviously I’m more knowledgable now, but that’s a different axis as far as I’m concerned (and still a valuable one)

Maxime M.'s avatar

I think old men are, as usual, an easy target. Of course, people of any age group doing bad science will negatively impact science quality. Your thesis here I don't totally disagree with - I just think the ideal time to argue that would have been half a decade ago. Because right now with underqualified AI-assisted students being awarded doctorates I really don't think you can argue young people are the demographic making the best science.

Adam Rochussen's avatar

Yes good point and I agree. My argument here is most salient in the context of my previous writing (eg the PhDs are easy essay). Most young scientists are bad because we’ve dropped standards severely. But for the small slice of excellent young scientists (the ones that would make disruptive discoveries), the field is sloped against them.

I think the triaging process I recommend here would work for achieving meritocracy between age groups but also within age groups.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 2
Comment deleted
Adam Rochussen's avatar

What do you mean by “open proposal processes”?

I’d be a fan of limiting all proposals to 1-2 pages. In general it takes real skill to condense ideas into fewer words, and this forces scientists to think saliently. AI is really bad at that right now